A simple method to verify the bandwidth of your probeFollow article
In oscilloscopes and oscilloscope probes, bandwidth is the width of a range of frequencies measured in Hertz. Specifically, bandwidth is specified as the frequency at which a sinusoidal input signal is attenuated to 70.7% of its original amplitude, also known as the -3 dB point. Most scope companies design the scope/probe response to be as flat as possible throughout its specified frequency range, and most customers simply rely on the specified bandwidth of the oscilloscope or oscilloscope probes. This often leaves them wondering if they are indeed getting the bandwidth performance at the probe tip. This article provides some step-by-step instructions on how to simply measure and verify the bandwidth of your probe with an oscilloscope you may already have.
Figure 1: An example of an Oscilloscope Gaussian frequency response
To measure the bandwidth of an oscilloscope probe, a VNA (vector network analyzer) is often used, which can be very expensive and difficult to learn how to use. Also, because typical passive probes are high impedance probes that should be terminated into 1 Mohm of an oscilloscope, it makes the traditional VNA s21 method hard to implement because it is 50 ohm based system.
The other way to get bandwidth is to use a sine wave source, a splitter, and a power meter and sweep the response directly. If you do this, you must set this up to run using a remote interface such as GPIB or USB. Doing it manually is very laborious, subject to mistakes, and requires extensive effort every time you want to evaluate a tweak, etc.
An easier way of measuring probe bandwidth, especially for the lower bandwidth probes (say, <1 GHz passive probe) is the time domain approach utilizing only an oscilloscope with the built-in step signal source, the ‘differentiate’ function, and the ‘FFT’. To be able to use this method, your oscilloscope should support the function of another function output. If you don't, an alternative is to pull the time domain waveform data out of the oscilloscope, import it into the PC based analysis tool such as Mathlab or Excel, and apply the math functions on the step data there.
When you apply a step function to your system, then you will get the step response. If you then apply the differentiate (or derivative) to this step response, you obtain the impulse response, and then take the FFT of the impulse response to obtain the frequency response of the system.
Keysight’s Infiniium real-time oscilloscope is an excellent tool for this quick bandwidth testing. Here is the step by step procedure of the testing. For this bandwidth measurement example, an N2873A 500MHz 10:1 passive probe, RS Stock No. with an Infiniium MSOS804A 8 GHz oscilloscope is used.
- Use a performance verification fixture such as Keysight’s E2655C with a 50 ohm BNC cable to connect the Aux output of the oscilloscope to the input of the oscilloscope. The Infiniium oscilloscope has an Aux output port with fast edge speed (~140 psec, 10-90% for Infinium S Series) for probe calibration. It is very important to note that the rise time of the signal source should be faster than the probe’s rise time, and the frequency response of the source is reasonably flat over frequency.
Figure 2: Probing 25 ohm signal source with the Keysight E2655C performance verification fixture
- Connect the probe to the PV fixture to measure one edge of the source. Use as short a probe ground as possible to reduce probe loading associated with ground leads.
Ch 1 (yellow) = signal source (Aux output) as loaded by the probe
Ch 2 (green) = the measured output of the probe
Figure 3: Probing fast edge
- Place the rising edges at the centre of the screen. Trigger on the measured output of the probe (ch2) and use the averaging or high-resolution acquisition to reduce the noise on the waveform.
- Use the oscilloscope’s built-in math function to differentiate the step response. Now you get the impulse response of the channel 2 where the probe is connected to. Assign the differentiated output of the step response into the F1 of the oscilloscope.
Figure 4: Use the oscilloscope’s built-in math function to differentiate the step response
- Apply the built-in FFT Magnitude function on the impulse response (F1) of the measured step signal. Rescale the FFT to 100MHz/div (the centre frequency at 500 MHz with the 1 GHz of frequency span across the screen) and 3dB/div vertically.
Figure 5: Apply the built-in FFT Magnitude function on the impulse response
- Now you have a plot of bandwidth. Since the vertical scale of the FFT plot is set to 3 dB/div with the horizontal scale set to 100 MHz/div, you can see the probe has ~660 MHz, as you pick the point in the FFT trace falling by 3 dB.
Figure 6: Now you have a plot of bandwidth
There is one catch to this. The way we do differentiate in some of the oscilloscopes is taking the best-fit slope to three adjacent points and then assign this slope to the centre point. This can really hose the bandwidth measurement up if you don't have enough sample density on the edge, so experiment with sample density and make sure it doesn't affect the bandwidth.
Utilising the built-in mathematical capabilities available in modern digital oscilloscopes, it is possible to derive the frequency response or the bandwidth characteristics of a probe based on the measured step response of a fast step signal. Among those several test methods, the time domain approach is the easiest for an oscilloscope user to duplicate without having a need to use expensive test instruments.